Japan looms large this week β€” Holland and Murray's Road to War series hits Parts 3 and 4, Mercogliano breaks down the shipbuilding that beat Tokyo, and even Rest Is History is doing samurai. But the Pick is Phil Watson on BEF doctrine, a proper dismantling of "lions led by donkeys."

🎯 This Week's Pick
Battles of the First World War artwork
British Doctrine in the Great War with Phil Watson
Battles of the First World War Β· 1h42m Β· Apr 12
Phil Watson β€” British Army veteran & University of Wolverhampton PhD candidate on BEF doctrine
World War ITactics & BattlesLeadership & Command

Phil Watson β€” a British Army veteran and PhD candidate at Wolverhampton researching BEF doctrine β€” joins for an extended conversation that goes straight at the 'lions led by donkeys' myth. The discussion covers whether the BEF actually had a coherent doctrine, the logic behind chΓ’teau command posts, and the real extent of mission command and decentralised leadership on the Western Front. At nearly two hours, this is serious WWI operational history with exactly the right guest for the subject.

Enjoying the digest? Share it with a friend — they can subscribe from the preview page.

πŸ”΄ Essential

Shipbuilding and Fleet Repair in the PTO with Sal Mercogliano – Episode 549
Unauthorized History of the Pacific War Β· 1h56m Β· Apr 07
Sal Mercogliano β€” maritime historian & YouTube creator (@wgowshipping); hosted by Seth Paridon (former chief historian, National WWII Museum) & Jon Parshall
World War IILogistics & SupplyNaval

Seth Paridon and Jon Parshall bring back maritime historian Sal Mercogliano for a nearly two-hour session on US Navy shipbuilding from the mid-1930s programmes through the Two Ocean Navy Act, plus the often-overlooked world of at-sea fleet repair in the Pacific. This is the unglamorous machinery of war done properly β€” the industrial backbone that made island-hopping possible and ultimately buried Japan's navy under a tonnage gap Tokyo could never close. If you care about how wars are actually won, this is your episode.

πŸ”— Pairs well with: Japan's Road To War: Countdown To Infamy (Part 4) (We Have Ways of Making You Talk)
Japan's Road To War: Countdown To Infamy (Part 4)
We Have Ways of Making You Talk Β· 50:16 Β· Apr 08
James Holland β€” WWII historian & Al Murray
World War IIStrategy & Grand Strategy

Holland and Murray continue their series on Japan's slide toward Pearl Harbor, focusing here on the military planning debates β€” what Japanese strategists thought was the best way to attack the United States, how Europe's war shifted American and Japanese policy, and the moment negotiations collapsed. With so much Japanese-focused content landing this week, this is the instalment that puts the strategic and operational calculus front and centre, and Holland keeps the narrative grounded in that military logic rather than letting it drift into pure diplomacy.

AW404 - The Marian Reforms
Ancient Warfare Podcast Β· 45:15 Β· Apr 10
Murray Dahm & the Ancient Warfare Magazine team
AncientTactics & Battles

The Ancient Warfare Magazine team tackle the Marian reforms β€” what they actually were versus the textbook version, and whether the transformation from citizen militia to professional army was as sharp a break as commonly assumed. Good corrective scholarship on one of the most important organisational shifts in military history. At 45 minutes it's tightly focused and well-informed.

🟑 Selections

Episode 616-Midway: First Blood
The History of WWII Podcast Β· 24:59 Β· Apr 07
Ray Harris Jr. β€” independent WWII historian
World War IINavalTactics & Battles

Ray Harris Jr. covers the opening blows of Midway β€” Fletcher's Yorktown versus Nagumo's First Air Fleet, with attention to the mistakes on both sides. Short at 25 minutes, which limits depth, but it's squarely on the battle.

πŸ”— Pairs well with: Shipbuilding and Fleet Repair in the PTO with Sal Mercogliano – Episode 549 (Unauthorized History of the Pacific War)
Japan's Road To War: Honne & Tatemae (Part 3)
We Have Ways of Making You Talk Β· 57:31 Β· Apr 06
James Holland β€” WWII historian & Al Murray
World War IIStrategy & Grand Strategy

Part 3 of the series examines how the Japanese cultural concept of honne and tatemae β€” the gap between private feelings and public presentation β€” may have contributed to the drift toward war, including the internal deadlines set for negotiations with the US. More cultural framing than Part 4 but still firmly anchored in the decision-making that led to conflict.

Episode 409 - The Anglo-Satsuma War
Lions Led By Donkeys Β· 1h37m Β· Apr 13
Peter Crean & Luke Robinson
19th CenturyNavalColonial & Imperial

Lions Led By Donkeys covers the 1863 bombardment of Kagoshima β€” the short, sharp naval confrontation between the Royal Navy and the Satsuma domain that most people have never heard of. A niche but genuinely interesting colonial-era clash with the show's trademark irreverence.

The Crusades: Assassins vs Templars
Dan Snow's History Hit Β· 47:07 Β· Apr 09
Steve Tibble β€” Crusades historian & author of Assassins and Templars
MedievalIntelligence & Espionage

Steve Tibble β€” a proper Crusades scholar β€” guides Dan Snow through the real history of the Assassins and Templars, separating the covert operations and beliefs from the mythology. Tibble's expertise elevates what could be a pop-culture exercise.

659. Dawn of the Samurai: Bloodbath at the Bridge (Part 2)
The Rest Is History Β· 1h07m Β· Apr 08
Tom Holland & Dominic Sandbrook
MedievalTactics & BattlesCivil War & Rebellion

Part 2 of the series covers the Minamoto clan's rise and the violent set-piece encounters of 12th-century Japan, adding yet another angle on Japanese military culture to a week already stacked with it. Solid storytelling from Holland and Sandbrook, with enough tactical colour to keep it military rather than purely cultural.

πŸ“Ž Catching up? Part 1: The Shadow of the Sword

πŸ“š Reading List

The Namamugi Incident: Its Origins and Aftermath — William de Lange

The show notes for the Anglo-Satsuma War episode list this as a source β€” it covers the 1862 killing of a British merchant by Satsuma retainers and the bizarre little war that followed, which is exactly the story the episode tells.

Via: Episode 409 - The Anglo-Satsuma War, Lions Led By Donkeys
πŸ“– Amazon UK
Countdown to Pearl Harbor: The Twelve Days to the Attack — Steve Twomey

Holland and Murray's Japan's Road to War series is deep into the diplomatic endgame and the military planning for war with the United States. Twomey's book zeroes in on those final days from the American side β€” a natural companion piece for Parts 3 and 4.

Via: Inspired by Japan's Road To War Parts 3 & 4, We Have Ways of Making You Talk
πŸ“– Amazon UK
Field Service Regulations 1909 — War Office

Phil Watson links directly to this document in the show notes β€” it's the actual British Army doctrinal manual that underpins the whole episode's argument that the BEF did, in fact, have a coherent doctrine. A primary source you can read for free, but there are reprints available too.

Via: British Doctrine in the Great War with Phil Watson, Battles of the First World War
πŸ“– Amazon UK

πŸ—“ This Week in Military History

Explore more: The Invasion of Malaya - Episode 531 (Unauthorized History of the Pacific War)
Explore more: How Did the American Revolution Start? (Dan Snow's History Hit)