Gaugamela earns the Pick — the Ancient Warfare team's multi-voice format suits a battle where the sources genuinely disagree, and it's the strongest roundtable they've done in months. Elsewhere, Lions Led By Donkeys finally giving the Imjin War proper coverage and Parshall's devastating Bataan episode make this an unusually strong week.

The Ancient Warfare Magazine team discusses their issue on Gaugamela — Alexander's decisive battle against Darius III in 331 BC. This is the battle that broke the Achaemenid Empire, and the podcast covers the tactical picture: Alexander's oblique advance, the gap that opened in the Macedonian line, the cavalry action on the flanks, and why Darius's numerical superiority couldn't translate into victory. The magazine-discussion format means multiple contributors weigh in with genuinely competing readings of the sources and the terrain, and it's that friction between interpretations — not a single narrator smoothing over the contradictions — that makes this the strongest roundtable the show has produced in months.
The traditional site lies near Tel Gomel in the plains east of Mosul, where the flat, open terrain Darius reportedly levelled for his chariots and cavalry is still visible in the landscape. The exact location has been debated since antiquity — Arrian placed it near the Bumodus River (modern Khazir). No systematic excavation of the battlefield has been conducted, partly due to decades of regional instability. The terrain itself, however, confirms the ancient sources: a broad, featureless plain ideally suited to the massed cavalry and chariot tactics Darius relied on, and precisely the ground Alexander's oblique advance was designed to disrupt.
⚖ The debate: Did Alexander's oblique phalanx advance at Gaugamela represent a deliberate, pre-planned maneuver or an opportunistic exploitation of gaps in the Persian line? Waldemar Heckel and J.F.C. Fuller argue for calculated tactical design; some scholars emphasize the role of terrain and Persian mistakes in creating the opening.
Seth Paridon and John Parshall walk through the final collapse of the Bataan defence — Wainwright's impossible position, Homma's fresh troops grinding down starving, malaria-ridden American and Filipino forces, and the grim logistics of a garrison that had everything except supplies. Parshall brings a level of operational rigour that makes the episode quietly devastating, and the show doesn't shy away from the command dilemmas: MacArthur's departure, the question of when capitulation becomes inevitable rather than dishonourable. At ninety minutes it earns the runtime, covering both the tactical endgame and the human cost without padding.
🏛 Where to see it: The American Battle Monuments Commission operates the Manila American Cemetery and Memorial in Fort Bonifacio, which holds records and memorials for American servicemen killed during the Bataan campaign and subsequent captivity.
🎙 Veterans' accounts: Library of Congress Veterans History Project holds 100+ interviews with World War II Pacific Theater veterans, including survivors of the Philippines campaign — searchable at loc.gov/vets
Dan Snow uses the 1908 sinking of HMS Tiger as a lens into the pre-dreadnought naval revolution — how steam, steel, and speed transformed warfare at sea faster than doctrine or training could keep up. The episode is properly about the technological and institutional challenges navies faced in adapting to radical change, not just the accident itself. A good entry point for anyone interested in the Fisher-era Royal Navy and the dangerous gap between new capabilities and old seamanship.
Harris digs into the Japanese failure at Edson's Ridge — Kawaguchi's attack faltering because a third of his force never engaged — and the Combined Fleet's subsequent decision to make Guadalcanal the priority. The episode is sharp on how tactical-level breakdowns (navigation in jungle, coordination failures) cascaded into strategic consequences. Good companion to Episode 646, and the better of the two this week.
🏛 Where to see it: The National WWII Museum in New Orleans holds extensive primary source documentation and artefacts related to the Guadalcanal campaign, including materials on the fighting at Edson's Ridge.
Lions Led By Donkeys finally gives Toyotomi Hideyoshi's 1592 invasion of Korea the coverage it deserves — a campaign that's criminally underserved in English-language podcasting. Part 1 sets up the political context and the opening Japanese assault, which overran the peninsula with shocking speed before Korean naval resistance and Ming Chinese intervention changed the equation. The show's irreverent style works well here because the material is unfamiliar enough that the commentary adds rather than distracts, and the result is proper coverage of a war that has waited too long for a good English-language treatment.
🏛 Where to see it: The National Museum of Korea in Seoul holds artefacts and documentation from the Imjin War (1592–1598), including ceramics, weapons, and period military equipment directly related to the Japanese invasion and Korean resistance.
A former East German Air Force officer named Roland describes training on MiGs, serving with Mi-8 helicopters, and the constant expectation of a NATO war — all wrapped in relentless political instruction. A rare first-person account from inside the NVA's air arm, and the tension between technical competence and ideological conformity is well drawn.
🏛 Where to see it: The Military History Museum of the Bundeswehr in Dresden documents the Nationale Volksarmee's air arm structure, training regimen, and Cold War operational posture through archival records and exhibits.
Eve MacDonald joins Tristan Hughes to cover Shapur I's campaigns against Rome — the defeat and capture of Emperor Valerian, the forging of Sasanian military power, and why Rome's eastern frontier was so persistently vulnerable. Properly military in framing, with the strategic dynamics of the Roman-Sasanian rivalry front and centre.
🏛 Where to see it: The British Museum holds Sasanian coins and seals from Shapur I's reign (r. 240–270 CE) that document the imperial iconography and administrative reach of the Sasanian Empire during its conflict with Rome.
Jamie Jeffers covers the 1106 Battle of Tinchebray — Henry I versus Robert Curthose for control of Normandy, the battle that reunited England and the duchy. The sequential format means you get the political build-up (the Anselm dispute delaying Henry's campaign) alongside the battle itself, and Jeffers is good on the stakes of Norman dynastic warfare.
Ray Harris Jr. covers the escalation spiral on Guadalcanal as both sides commit to pouring in reinforcements after the near-run fight at Edson's Ridge. Brief but focused on the operational stakes.
Listed as a source for the Lions Led By Donkeys episode on Hideyoshi's catastrophic Korean invasion. Hawley's account is the go-to English-language treatment of a conflict that killed over a million people and tends to fall through the cracks between Japanese, Korean, and Chinese historiography.
The Unauthorized History episode covers the final collapse on Bataan and hints at the horrors to come. This is the definitive account of what happened next — the Death March and the captivity that followed — told through the voices of the men who survived it.
Two History of WWII Podcast episodes this week cover the fighting around Edson's Ridge and the escalation that followed. Richard Frank's book remains the single best volume on the entire campaign — land, sea, and air — and pairs perfectly with these episodes.
The Ancients episode on Shapur I explores how a single ruler rebuilt Persian power and humiliated Rome. Daryaee's concise history covers the full arc of the dynasty Shapur helped forge, giving you the wider context for that extraordinary capture of Valerian.
If a friend would find this useful, send them the link. That’s the entire growth strategy.